Zenith Aircraft Builders and Flyers

Build It! Fly It! The Companion Website to the Zenair Newsletter

Sebastien Heintz

Installing Micro Vortex Generators on the STOL CH 701 Elevator

Over the past year we have been testing micro vortex generators (VG) on the bottom of the STOL elevator. We've been using them on our factory demo planes and have sent out samples to experienced STOL pilots, including CH 701 owner and pilot Bob Jones (of Alaska).

We manufactured our own micro vortex generators out of .020 6061-T6 aluminum in our hydraulic press to match the curvature of the elevator, and for maximum durability and ease of installation.

A while back, designer Chris Heintz wrote an article on the use of VG's on the STOL CH 701. He explained how VG's "may improve the stall on small leading edge radius airfoils (so-called laminar airfoils) by “pumping” energy from the free airstream into the boundary layer which will then separate at a higher angle of attack, and the airfoil will have a larger maximum lift coefficient, thus reducing the stall speed. Note also that because of the above-mentioned “energizing” of the boundary layer with the use of VGs, the local stall can be delayed on a large deflection of a control surface, as illustrated below on the STOL elevator:"

We've since tried a number of different VG's on the bottom of the elevator (as shown above) with good results, allowing us to approach and to land the aircraft at even slower speeds. We've been using the micros VG's on all the STOL aircraft, including the new STOL CH 750 model. Some different micro VG types on the market:

In February, Bob Jones installed his VG's and explained: "They went on very fast... the VG turned 180 degrees makes an ideal spacer." Shown below with the STOL CH 701 elevator removed from the aircraft (the VG's are installed on the bottom of the elevator):

"It took 15 per side, the tape edge makes a perfect guide." Note that we made the VG's with pre-drilled pilot holes. Two sided tape (such as carpet tape) can be used instead of rivets (at least until you establish the optimum location).

The installed vortex generators:

Last week, Bob had the chance to fly his 701 with the VG's in place. Bob Jones has been flying his CH701 in Alaska for a number of years, utilizing the STOL characteristics of the design on skis and floats. He reports: "There is a very noticeable change. I was able to fly the length of my runway at a true ground speed of 38mph. as slow as it would go and maintain altitude but not so fast as to climb, I was able to slow my normal approach to 45 mph and have a nice steady descent rate, with a noticeable decrease in rpm needed to keep good elevator control. The transition from no VG effect (no elevator deflection) to vg effect (elevator deflection) is very noticeable - like flipping a switch. You know I push the boundary some and I think the only negative is that without a tail skid you could get into trouble. Testing them has been a rewarding experience that I would definitely recommend!!!"

We plan to keep testing these VG's for optimum location (this doesn't seem to be a real science!) and will make them available to builders and flyers who want maximum short take-off and landing performance with their aircraft.


Retired airline pilot Viktor Strausak has been flying his Zodiac CH 601 HDS for many years now with many VGs in various locations. He has posted some impressive photos! (Follow the link to his webpage for many more photos and info).

Tags: generator, lift, micro, slat, vg, vortex

Comment

You need to be a member of Zenith Aircraft Builders and Flyers to add comments!

Join Zenith Aircraft Builders and Flyers

jim miller Comment by jim miller on February 8, 2010 at 1:11am
Hi
I am scratch building a 701 and would like to turn some of my scrap into vgs does any one know where to get some dimensions
thanks jim miller
Jack Williams Comment by Jack Williams on August 5, 2009 at 4:06pm
Has anyone installed VGs on an 801. What are your results?
Bob Collins Comment by Bob Collins on August 3, 2009 at 5:30pm
I agree with Bob Simmons: A skid with some stiff "springiness" would be preferable to a wheel. It could be lighter and it shouldn't need to be dragged far. The example Chumphol Sirinavin shows, which is hard mounted, looks like it would rattle my teeth if it ever hit: better than not having it but I feel that there must be something better.
Bob Simmons Comment by Bob Simmons on July 15, 2009 at 12:18pm
I would prefer to install something that's angled aft so as to minimize rearward or lateral forces that could theoretically cause the fuselage to bend at the attach point, such as the skid/wheel run into a small mound of dirt on a rough runway. Something like this would preserve the tiedown.


But your post did give me ideas on an installation point. Thanks.
Chumphol Sirinavin Comment by Chumphol Sirinavin on July 15, 2009 at 12:16pm
If needed, a small wheel can be installed in place of the tail tie-down.


You can see that this wheel, attached to a 701SP (with no VG's installed) scrapes dirt from runway whenever the pilot over-rotates on takeoff or landing. The rudder has been removed for paint touch-up on the lower end.
Bob Simmons Comment by Bob Simmons on July 15, 2009 at 11:00am
So how would one go about installing a tail skid?
Sebastien Heintz Comment by Sebastien Heintz on June 24, 2009 at 5:50pm
Zenith Aircraft now offers a kit for the formed aluminum VGs to install on the bottom of the elevator on the STOL CH 701, STOL CH 750 or the four seat STOL CH 801.
Zenith.Aero Comment by Zenith.Aero on June 24, 2009 at 4:35pm
More info: John Brooker's STOL CH 701 with the micro Vortex Generators.
Video of Bob Jones' STOL CH 701 with the micro Vortex Generators
Kostas Rossidis Comment by Kostas Rossidis on May 5, 2009 at 8:57am
When you finish testing I would like to install vgs on my plane too!!
Chumphol Sirinavin Comment by Chumphol Sirinavin on March 23, 2009 at 1:18pm
Sebastien,

Thanks for the VG's. They have made quite an improvement in low speed control.
I have watched the video. Some extreme attitude indeed, on touch down. A tail skid with replaceable shoe, or a tail wheel, may be needed in no-snow landing.

Champ

Subcribe to Zenair News


Zenair News is the official newsletter for builders and owners of Zenith aircraft. Now in color, and FREE bonus DVD with every issue!

New from Zenith:

NEW super-bright LED lights for your Zenith:

These Zenair-branded 3-way wingtip-mounted LED lights from AeroLED are the brightest and highest quality LED lights available on the market today. Available at a great price exclusively for Zenith builders and owners.

The official Zenith Aircraft DVD has been updated with new footage and features, and now includes the STOL CH 750 and the ZODIAC CH 650.

© 2010   Created by Zenith.Aero

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service